CampaignStack
How to find prospects engaging with competitor posts on LinkedIn

How to find prospects engaging with competitor posts on LinkedIn

CampaignStack8 min read

Your competitors post on LinkedIn every week. Under each post, people react, repost and comment, and on a public post anyone can see who they are. Some of them are exactly the buyers you want. They have the problem, and they just said so in public.

Most teams know this and never do anything with it. Reading engagement by hand is slow, and the list goes stale while you work. The manual way below works. It also eats hours, and that is the part a tool should take.

Why engagement on a competitor's post is worth reading

A post about a problem pulls in people who have that problem. When the post comes from a company that sells a fix, the people who stop to engage are often shopping around or living with a tool they don't love.

It is also public. LinkedIn says a post set to "Anyone" is "visible to anyone on or off LinkedIn", and that the posts you like or react to are shared with your network. Nothing here is hidden data. You are reading the same thread every other reader sees. Write to them the way you'd talk to anyone else in that thread.

Not all engagement is equal

What each kind of engagement tells you: a reaction is one click, a repost shares the idea, a comment puts their own words and often their problem in publicWhat each kind of engagement tells you: a reaction is one click, a repost shares the idea, a comment puts their own words and often their problem in public

  • A reaction takes one click. LinkedIn offers Like plus Celebrate, Support, Love, Insightful and Funny. A reaction tells you someone saw the post and felt something. Friends, colleagues and the author's own team react to everything.
  • A repost says "my network should see this." Stronger, though it is often more about the author than the problem.
  • A comment is the best signal by far. The person wrote words, in public, under their own name. "We're dealing with exactly this" or "How does this work with HubSpot?" tells you what they need. "Great post!" tells you almost nothing.

So read the comments first. Reactions go on a list to check later, if at all. Nobody earns a message with one click.

The manual way, step by step

Step 1: Pick whose posts to watch

Start with three to five competitors whose buyers match your client's ideal customer. Add a few creators in your niche whose audience is your buyer, too. Follow their company pages and profiles so their posts show up in your feed.

Step 2: Open each new post and read the engagement

Open the post. Expand the comments, including replies. Then open the list of people who reacted. On a popular post it runs long.

Step 3: Check each person against your ideal customer

For every comment that sounds like a buyer, open the profile. Check the title, the company, the size, the country. Most won't fit. Some are the competitor's own staff, partners or other vendors. Skip them.

Step 4: Copy the good ones to a sheet

Paste the name, profile link, title, company, the post link and what they said. Then dedupe: the same people comment on every post from the same company.

Step 5: Write to them, one by one

Look at what they wrote, then write a message that starts from their problem. Send a connection request or a message. Note who answers.

Step 6: Do it again tomorrow

New posts every day. Comments keep arriving on older posts for days. So you go back to the same posts, and you start again on the new ones.

The manual way: open each new post, read every comment and reaction, check each profile against your ideal customer, copy the good ones to a sheet, write to each one, then repeat for every new postThe manual way: open each new post, read every comment and reaction, check each profile against your ideal customer, copy the good ones to a sheet, write to each one, then repeat for every new post

What that costs you

Count the posts. This is arithmetic, not a measurement: five companies posting three times a week is 15 posts a week. Each one needs a first read, then a second and third visit as comments trickle in. Every person who looks right is another profile to open.

The tools are LinkedIn, a spreadsheet, and Sales Navigator if you have it. Sales Navigator won't do this part for you. Its lead filters cover people who follow your company, viewed your profile or posted in the last 30 days. None of them finds people who engaged with another company's posts.

It works. It just never survives a busy week.

Where CampaignStack takes over

CampaignStack does the reading and the first sort. You still pick who to watch and you approve what goes out.

You start by adding a watch. In Signals, open Watchers and choose Add Profile. Paste a LinkedIn company page or a person's profile. Pick which of your LinkedIn accounts read the posts ("Reads with") and which send ("Sends from"). Leave "Sends from" empty and it only collects people, without contacting anyone. You can run up to 10 active watches.

From there it finds new posts on its own. Every hour it reads up to 20 recent posts from each watched page or profile. A new post is re-read often while it is fresh, every 15 minutes on its first day, then less often, and it stops after 21 days, so late comments still get picked up. Each watch holds up to 15 posts at a time. On a page that posts a lot, that means some posts get skipped.

Each new comment is sorted as buyer intent, interest or plain engagement, and a comment that fits none of them is dropped. Then each commenter is scored against your ideal customer profiles. A strong fit gets a drafted message or connection request. A weaker fit may get a like only, and a poor fit gets nothing. Your exclusion list runs first, so vendors and competitors you've excluded never get through, and someone picked up in the last 60 days is skipped unless their new comment shows stronger intent.

You review before anything sends. The drafts land in your review queue by default. When a connection request goes out, nothing else is sent until it's accepted. If the person doesn't answer your message, one follow-up is drafted after four days of silence, also for your review.

Reactions and reposts are collected and shown on the watch, but CampaignStack only reaches out to commenters. That's the point of the section above: a comment is the signal worth acting on.

Where CampaignStack takes over: you choose who to watch and approve the drafts; CampaignStack finds new posts every hour, re-reads each one for 21 days, sorts the comments, scores each commenter against your ideal customer and drafts a message for reviewWhere CampaignStack takes over: you choose who to watch and approve the drafts; CampaignStack finds new posts every hour, re-reads each one for 21 days, sorts the comments, scores each commenter against your ideal customer and drafts a message for review

It costs credits: 1 per post check, and the step that decides and drafts is charged by what it does (nothing when it takes no action). Every LinkedIn read also counts against that account's own daily read budget.

How to write to someone who commented on a competitor

Most of these messages go wrong in the first line.

  • Don't open with the post. "I saw your comment on Acme's post" reads like you're watching them. Open with the problem they named, in your words.
  • Don't trash the competitor. They may be a happy customer. Offer a different angle or ask a question.
  • Answer what they asked. If they asked "does this work for agencies?", and the author never replied, a short honest answer is a great first message.
  • Keep it short. One reason to talk, one easy next step.

What to watch out for

  • The author's circle comments first. Staff, partners and friends fill the first comments on most posts. Check the company on every profile.
  • "Great post" is not intent. Volume of comments means little. Read what they said.
  • Comments can be turned off. Authors can limit comments to connections or switch them off. Some posts give you nothing to read.
  • Your LinkedIn account carries the risk. LinkedIn's User Agreement bans scraping and bots that comment, like or send messages. No tool can promise an account will never be restricted. Read slowly, send within your daily limits, and review what goes out.

Takeaway

The people commenting under a competitor's post told you what they care about, in public. Read the comments, not the like count. Check each person against your ideal customer, and write to their problem, never to the fact that you saw them. Do it by hand for a week to learn the pattern, then let a tool do the reading so it still happens when you're busy.

Sources

  1. linkedin.com/help/linkedin/answer/a522684
  2. linkedin.com/help/linkedin/answer/a523141
  3. linkedin.com/help/linkedin/answer/a528176
  4. linkedin.com/help/linkedin/answer/a528190
  5. linkedin.com/help/sales-navigator/answer/a1452817
  6. linkedin.com/legal/user-agreement